logo
Reply
Thread Tools
Old 02-20-2007, 10:27 PM
GRAVITY SUCKS
rede2fly's Avatar
florida
Joined Jan 2006
4,798 Posts
BALANCING GIANT AIRPLANES

hey guys dont want to sound like a idoit here but, what balancer are you using to balance airplanes that are say around or over 20 lbs?? all i have is the great planes balancer and i dont trust it to cary that much weight. plus it isnt very user friendley when trying to balance bigger planes. whats out there??
rede2fly is offline Find More Posts by rede2fly
Reply With Quote
Old 02-20-2007, 10:30 PM
Bad-ass Super Contributor!
Pale Rider's Avatar
NJ
Joined Jan 2006
1,372 Posts
Re: BALANCING GIANT AIRPLANES

.
Pale Rider is offline Find More Posts by Pale Rider
Last edited by Pale Rider; 02-21-2007 at 10:24 PM. Reason: because
Reply With Quote
Old 02-20-2007, 10:44 PM
Learn how to work Kid.
Wayne's Avatar
Bloomington, Il
Joined Jan 2006
7,402 Posts
Re: BALANCING GIANT AIRPLANES

I posted this a long time ago on RCU..
It works!

This method is how I go about checking CG on a plane that weighs too much to put on a CG machine. This is generally the same way full scale planes are balanced. You can’t go lifting a 747 by your fingers!


First, have the plane assembled as
RTF, but minus fuel. Find a place where you can put the nose of the plane up against a wall. Take a level and prop up the tail wheel until the fuselage is sitting level. You will probably have to take the hatch off in most cases to find a suitable area to set the level on.

Once the plane is sitting level, place masking tape under the area where the main wheels are touching the surface and draw a line where the wheels contact the tape. Make an index mark where the center of the tailwheel falls in the same manner. This mark will be on whatever you propped the tail up with. (I use magazines). It’s also a good time to measure from the wall, to the point where the recommended CG is. Save that number for later.

What you are looking for at this point is the distance to each wheel from the tip of the spinner. (which should be touching the wall at this point) I use a long straightedge to get the distances

As an example, let’s say you come up with theses numbers:
LH main – 22”
RH main – 22”
Tailwheel – 70”

Now, place a scale under each wheel individually. You will have to re-adjust the height of the other wheels each time to keep the plane sitting level. Add more magazines as necessary. (If you have three scales you can get the weights at the same time but make sure the plane is level)
Don’t forget to re-install the hatch before you weigh each wheel. You will wind up with three weights, one for each wheel.

Let’s say you come up with these numbers
LH main – 9 lbs
RH main – 9 lbs
Tailwheel – 5 lbs

Now its just a simple math problem to find where the CG sits right now on the plane.

Weight x ARM (distance) = Moment
22x9=198 in-lbs
22x9=198 in-lbs
70x5=350 in-lbs

Now add the total of all the moments and the total of all the weights.
Weights 9+9+5 = 23lbs
moments 198+198+350 = 746

Then divide the total moments by the total weights.
746 divided by 23 = 32.43

That number 32.43 is "in inches" how far back from the tip of the spinner to where the plane balances right now.
Compare that to the distance that you measured earlier to the recommended CG location.
If you are off one way or another adjust items then recalculate the weights. The distances (or ARM's) arent going to change so you already have those numbers.


Wayne is offline Find More Posts by Wayne
Reply With Quote
Old 02-21-2007, 10:21 PM
GRAVITY SUCKS
rede2fly's Avatar
florida
Joined Jan 2006
4,798 Posts
Re: BALANCING GIANT AIRPLANES

thanks wayne. i knew i was saving my 15 year old mags for something. thats a lot to take in, after only reading once. think ill have to print this out
rede2fly is offline Find More Posts by rede2fly
Reply With Quote
Old 02-21-2007, 10:24 PM
Learn how to work Kid.
Wayne's Avatar
Bloomington, Il
Joined Jan 2006
7,402 Posts
Re: BALANCING GIANT AIRPLANES

It looks worse than it is.
Pretty simple to do.
Wayne is offline Find More Posts by Wayne
Reply With Quote
Old 02-21-2007, 11:21 PM
GRAVITY SUCKS
rede2fly's Avatar
florida
Joined Jan 2006
4,798 Posts
Re: BALANCING GIANT AIRPLANES

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pale Rider View Post
.
hey pale rider why did you pull your post?? i didnt have a chance to go look at it.
rede2fly is offline Find More Posts by rede2fly
Reply With Quote
Old 02-24-2007, 05:43 AM
Registered User
digger44's Avatar
Newnan, Georgia
Joined Jan 2006
80 Posts
Re: BALANCING GIANT AIRPLANES

I downloaded this spreaadsheet from some where but for the life of me I can't remember. Havn't tried it yet but it is basically the same method that Wayne described above except total weight of the model is needed. At the time I found this, those that used it said it worked well. Any way, it might be worth a shot. I will be attempting this myself in a week or so.
digger44 is offline Find More Posts by digger44
Reply With Quote
Old 02-25-2007, 08:11 PM
GRAVITY SUCKS
rede2fly's Avatar
florida
Joined Jan 2006
4,798 Posts
Re: BALANCING GIANT AIRPLANES

thanks digger ill take a look at it
rede2fly is offline Find More Posts by rede2fly
Reply With Quote
Old 04-14-2008, 08:21 PM
Flyin' Around
Cold Spring Harbor, New York
Joined Jan 2007
5 Posts
Re: BALANCING GIANT AIRPLANES

WAYNE...... That is great. I took my A&P (Airframe & Power Plant) a lot of years ago. That really takes me back. You are spot on.... Thanks Jay P.
BigDuke1 is offline Find More Posts by BigDuke1
Reply With Quote
Old 04-14-2008, 08:23 PM
Learn how to work Kid.
Wayne's Avatar
Bloomington, Il
Joined Jan 2006
7,402 Posts
Re: BALANCING GIANT AIRPLANES

Jay,

As you know, I didnt make it up.
Just passing it along.
Wayne is offline Find More Posts by Wayne
Reply With Quote
Old 04-14-2008, 08:59 PM
Registered User
reyn3545's Avatar
United States, GA, Atlanta
Joined Oct 2006
10,051 Posts
Re: BALANCING GIANT AIRPLANES

Most of the larger planes will tell you to start out with the plane balanced on the wing tube, so just take the canopy off, grab the tube (lightly) and lift.

Some obviously won't have wing tubes (warbirds) or will balance at different points... the above weighting method works great.
reyn3545 is online now Find More Posts by reyn3545
Reply With Quote
Old 04-23-2008, 01:15 PM
Flyin' Around
showme3d's Avatar
Jonesboro, AR
Joined Apr 2007
40 Posts
Re: BALANCING GIANT AIRPLANES

If the balance point is the wing tube. I take a string and make a loop on both end. Put the loops over both sides of the wing tube (with tube thru plane) put the wings on and all other parts (canopy, cowling, etc). Lift the plane off of the ground by the string, should be pretty easy to see if it is balanced.
showme3d is offline Find More Posts by showme3d
Reply With Quote
Old 04-23-2008, 01:41 PM
Uber Contributor
crhammond's Avatar
Edmonton, AB, Canada
Joined Mar 2006
976 Posts
Re: BALANCING GIANT AIRPLANES

I made a simple balancing jig so I can do it by myself with some accuracy. There are also after market ones available but they are expensive. I bought an after market one to share with friends but they are easy enough to make. http://www.ezbalancer.com/index.html I got the version 1 for large planes and have used it for many planes at the club. It is more easily adjustable than the wood one I made. I see they have a new version that looks very nice too.

If you want to make one...
Basically you make some "cradles" out of ply(1/2") (padded with some pipe insulation foam) that the wings sit on near the root. Those are bolted through a bushing onto some ply supports (3/4".) You make a line that runs throught the pivot point of the bolt and use this to "sight" the CG mark. You should also add some stops to the side rails so that the cradles cannot tip so far that the plane would fall. The supports are bolted to a frame of some type. I used some aluminum brackets on a 3x4 ply sheet so I can move the cradles in and out to support the plane near the fuse.

I set the jig up on some sawhorses and then lift the airplane onto the cradles. It is very accurate and you can move batteries around and play with weights while it is up there.

As has been mentioned almost all giant monoplanes balance on the wing tube - but not all. Biplanes are also different. Thats another reason why I like the jig.
crhammond is offline Find More Posts by crhammond
Reply With Quote
Old 04-23-2008, 04:50 PM
Registered User
hawk21's Avatar
Aguadilla, Puerto Rico
Joined Mar 2006
282 Posts
Re: BALANCING GIANT AIRPLANES

the gp cg machine works, can handle up to 40 pounds
I have use it, but it is dificult to put the plane
hawk21 is offline Find More Posts by hawk21
Reply With Quote
Old 05-24-2008, 08:11 PM
Flyin' Around
Dennis 9412's Avatar
Washago, Ontario
Joined Oct 2006
38 Posts
Re: BALANCING GIANT AIRPLANES

You might want to try the Vanessa rig. You can make one of these for about $2.00 and it will work with any size plane. I didn't believe it would work, so I figured, "what do I have to lose but a couple bucks?"

I built one to balance my 28% WH Edge 540 and it works slicker than can be!!

Have a look here, and give it a try.

http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/m_708060/tm.htm
Dennis 9412 is online now Find More Posts by Dennis 9412
Reply With Quote
Reply



Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Category Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
What is Giant Style? All Thumbs General Discussion 8 05-09-2007 07:29 AM
A GIANT Flying Giant Experience snap a saurus General Discussion 26 04-28-2007 10:05 PM
Giant Scale Air Racing by Vess LeadingEdge General Discussion 24 08-23-2006 04:55 PM
16 Reasons Fearless Flyer Humor 5 03-15-2006 11:06 PM
Why airplanes are better! crazyextra Humor 6 02-08-2006 06:53 PM